home   contact   about   sitemap  
 
Books
 
Broken Dragons
Crime and Corruption
in today's China
by Bruce Dalbrack
A look at the darker side of the Chinese economic miracle
Buy the book!
Thoughts
this website
internet
 
China's changing dynasties
2002 | Opinion archive
The Asian continental landmass known today as China is usually disunited and split in smaller countries more than it is united in one big country. Over two-thirds of previous Chinese adminsitrtions in fact ruled a divided country. The current Communist regime in China is well into its fifth decade but it is unlikely they will see out the twenty-first century. Some interesting numbers on just how long they'll last

Guessing what will happen to China in future is a mugs game. The country is unusual for being so large and so continental and having such an irregular history of regime change. Moreover virtually all lists of Chinese dynasties have different dates. This inconsistency is striking before western historians started monitoring China (ie, after around 1644) and isa rather telling comment on the accuracy on China's historical record keeping. (This useful source has different dates to everybody else but has the advantage of containing the Chinese characters of different dynasties.)

Nonetheless there are a few safe insights from China’s past. Foremost of these conclusions is that China is like all other countries: it has dynasties and ruling eras that come and go. No leader lasts for ever. The table below lists the previous thirty or so administrations of China. This is not all that is claimed within the often dubious history of the Middle Kingdom but starts from around 1776 BCE; so, around four thousand years.

The last thirty or so regimes in China's history show not a united country but a disunited and turbulent continent. In fact the first united regime of what is today called China was the Chin era. This lasted for a very brief fifteen years from 221-206 BCE. Since then most dynasties in China have usually lasted under a century. Few make it past a hundred years although there are exceptions to this rule. Longer lived dynasties include the Shang/Yin era that may have lasted 654 years (1776-1122 BCE), the Western Chou may have survived for 352 years (1122-770 BCE) and the Eastern Chou may have survived for 241 years (722-481 BCE). Three dynasties from later periods are also long lived: the Tang lasted 289 years (618-907), the Ming lasted 294 years (1368-1662) and the Qing lasted 268 years (1644-1912). 

Assuming these dynasties and dates are somewhat accurate over the last few dozen rulers China has been united 12 times (35%) and disunited 22 times (65%). Thus for most of the time China has been divided between competing entities. 

Disunited regimes last for 119 years. This is slightly longer (+25%)  compared to 97 years for united regimes.

Given so many changes of administrations in China, regardles of whether the continetnal landmass was united or disunited, last not so long it is fair to say the Communists are lasting quite well. They are already approaching six decades. That makes them longer lived than several past regimes in China though far younger from the longest lived. So t he Communists probably have further to go. As noted most of China's dynasties have come and gone within a handful of decades. Some odd outliers push this average to 275 years. But the average of the last ten dynasties is much less: 97 years. Should this hold into the twenty-first century then the Communists are already past two-thirds of their shelf-life.

Table: Dynasties in China with (vaguely) reliable records

DYNASTY
OR ERA

(Footprint)

APPROX
START

APPROX
FINISH

LENGTH
IN YEARS

Shang/Yin

(North)

BCE 1776

BCE 1122

654

Western Chou

(North)

BCE 1122

BCE 770

352

Eastern Chou;
Spring & Autumn

(North, South)

BCE 722 

BCE 481 

241 

Yueh

(North, South)

BCE 481 

BCE 403 

78 

Eastern Chou;
Warring States 

(North, South)

BCE 403 

BCE 221 

182 

Chin

(United)

BCE 221 

BCE 206 

15 

Earlier Han 

(United)

BCE 206 

214 

Hsin 

(United)

23 

15 

Later Han

(North, South)

23 

220 

197 

Three Kingdoms

(North, South)

220 

280 

60 

Western Chin

(United)

265 

304 

39 

Eastern Chin

(North, South)

317 

420 

103 

Liu Sung

(South)

420 

479 

59 

Sixteen Kingdoms

(North)

304 

439 

135 

Northern Wei

(North)

386 

535 

149 

Southern Chi 

(South)

479 

502 

23 

Liang 

(South)

502 

557 

55 

Chen

(South)

557 

589 

32 

Sui

(United)

581 

618 

37 

Western Wei

(North) 535 

557 

22 

 

Northern Chou

(North)

557 

581 

24 

Eastern Wei

(North)

534 

550 

16 

Northern Chi

(North) 

550 

577

27 

Tang

(United)

618 

907

289
 

Ten Kingdoms 

(North)

907 

979 

72 

Five Dynasties

(North)

907 

960 

53 

Sung

(United)

960 

1126 

166 

Southern Sung

(South)

1127 

1279 

152 

Chin

(North)

1125 

1234 

109 

Mongols, later Yuan

(United)

1271 

1368 

97 

Ming

(United)

1368 

1662 

294 

Qing

(United)

1644 

1912

268 

Nationalist

(United)

1912

1949

37

People's Republic

(United)

1949

2010

60

 Average (all) 275 years
Average (last 10 administrations) 97 years
   

 
Plugs
Links