home   contact   about   sitemap  
 
Books
 
Broken Dragons
Crime and Corruption
in today's China
by Bruce Dalbrack
A look at the darker side of the Chinese economic miracle
Buy the book!
Thoughts
this website
internet
 
Iraq and its the neighbours
FEBRUARY 2004 | Opinion archive
Iraq's record on corruption is the worst among countries with which it shares borders. Their economy is also a mess and Iraqi GDP is one fifth of what it was in 1980. This is the biggest drop in the region. But looking at which of Iraq's neighbours will democratise next and it's clear that Turkey is the big hope and Iran is the big challenge

     
GDP
growth
Democracy
growth
 
Population
millions,
2005
Corruption
score,
2005
1980
2005
%
1980
2005
Ratio
Iraq 25 m 2.1 $3,274 $594 (18%) 0.0 0.0 Unchanged
Turkey 67 m 3.2 $1,491
$3,418 230% 0.0 20.4 x20
Iran 66 m 2.9 $2,321 $2,079 (90%) 3.7 2.9 (x0.8)
Saudi 26 m 3.4 $15,365

$8,561 (56%) 0.0 0.0 Unchanged
Syria 14 m 3.4 $1,458
$1,479 103% 0.0 0.0 Unchanged
Jordan 6 m 5.3 $1,803
$1,803 0% 0.0 0.2 x0
Kuwait 2 m 4.6 $20,867 $13,641 (65%) 0.0 0.8 x1
All Iraqi neigbours 181 m 3.8 $7,218
$5,167 (90%) 0.6 4.2 x7
Sources
Corruption scores: Transparency International
Democratisation: Finnish Social Science Data Archive
GDP & population:  United Nations

The table profiles Iraq’s neighbours over the last twenty-five years (from 1980-2005). Two vital measures have changed over these years: the level of GDP and the pace of democratization. Unfortunately neither have changed much for the better. Astonishingly GDP has fallen everywhere except Turkey. This seems scarcely believeable given two of the countries, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, are so oil rich.

Democratization is improving but erratically. Twenty-five years ago when there was zip or little democracy around only Iran had a murmur though this reflected the replacement of the Shah rather than what he was replaced by. Things have gone backwards in Iran and also Saudi Arabia.

Only secular Turkey has made useful progress in democratisation and is around twenty times more democratic in 2005 than in 1980. It's GDP has also more than doubled. Ankara can be proud they now scores over 20 points for democracy. That’s immeasurably better than anyone else in this list (though it’s still far behind western democracies like the UK and US, who score around the 50 mark). A decade from now it will hopefully be even better. Then, Turkey and it’s 67 millions – more than the population of either France or Germany or Britain – could be either the border of the European Union or potentially inside the European Union.

Understanding how Syria will play it’s hand is in many ways an understanding of how France will play their hand and have played their hand in the region. Syria was for many years a French colony. Annexed in 1920 - the French declared ‘the whole of it, and forever!’ - it once stretched as far as Lebanon. In 1919, barely eight decades ago, Britain and France were clashing over Iraq – then called Mesopotamia. (Iraq was only born in 1925). Then as now the French only acquiesced in the British creation of Iraq when they were granted an economic interest. Things change, and then again they never change. 


 
Plugs
Links